The community of
Surprise Lake
Miami Beach, Florida · $2,095,000 – $6,350,000
- For sale
- 5
- Under contract
- 1
- Median price
- $3,900,000
- Price / sq ft
- $1,477
- Avg days on market
- 103
- Built
- 1928–2025
Living here
Surprise Lake is a single-family community in Miami Beach, Florida. 5 residences are currently offered for sale, priced from $2,095,000 to $6,350,000; the median asking price is $3,900,000 (about $1,477 per square foot). 1 listing is already under contract — a live read on demand here. Construction here spans 1928 to 2025. 2 rentals are also available at a median of $30,000 per month.
- Pool views
- Garden views
- Entrance Foyer
- Closet Cabinetry
- Built-in Features
- Walk-In Closet(s)
- Storage
- Sidewalks
- Street Lights
- Game Room
On the market in Surprise Lake
$6,350,000
5 bd · 7 ba · 3,746 sf
4534 Sheridan Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of Compass Florida, LLC
$5,400,000
5 bd · 6 ba · 3,646 sf
4504 Sheridan Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of GuildStone Group LLC
$3,900,000
4 bd · 3 ba · 2,805 sf
4580 Post Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of BHHS EWM Realty
$2,295,000
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,554 sf
4500 Sheridan Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of The Corcoran Group
$2,190,000
4 bd · 6 ba · 2,783 sf
4575 Post Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of Miami Dreams Realty Inc.
$2,095,000
4 bd · 2 ba · 1,855 sf
4531 Sheridan Avenue, Miami Beach, FL 33140
Listing courtesy of Compass Florida, LLC
Maison Azure — Surprise Lake specialists
Own a home in Surprise Lake? Know what it's worth today.
We track every listing, contract and price move in Surprise Lake — the numbers on this page are live. Get a private, no-obligation valuation from the team that knows this community best.
Surprise Lake — questions we hear
- What is the median home price in Surprise Lake?
- The median asking price in Surprise Lake is currently $3,900,000, which works out to roughly $1,477 per square foot. Listings range from $2,095,000 to $6,350,000.
- How many homes are for sale in Surprise Lake right now?
- 5 homes are listed for sale, and 1 more is under contract. Inventory updates continuously from BeachesMLS.
- How quickly do homes sell in Surprise Lake?
- Active listings in Surprise Lake have averaged 103 days on market. Well-priced homes — like the 1 currently under contract — can move considerably faster.
- What schools serve Surprise Lake?
- Listings in Surprise Lake most commonly reference North Beach, Miami Beach Nautilus, Miami Beach. School assignments can vary by address — always verify with the district.